The Trouble With Magic by Madelyn Alt is the book our mystery group will be discussing on Wednesday, October 13. The first in a series, it's a part of the paranormal cozy mystery sub-genre that sprang into existece a few years ago (and still thrives). It's the story of a disatisfied office worker, Maggie O'Neill, who literally falls into a new job at an upscale shop. She rather quickly finds out that her new boss, Felicity Dow, is a self-described witch.
Among the themes in the book Maggie, raised in a Catholic family, learns to reconcilie her earlier religion with her respect for and friendship with Felicity. Lots of discussion about tolerance and freedom of religion, but it never sounds preachy. There's also some fun references to popular culture (Magnum P.I., particularly). The story really gets going, though, when Felicity's sister is killed and Felicity is suspected of the murder. Maggie is determined to prove she's innocent, and continuously battles with the detective assigned to the case. The growing attraction between them doesn't make things any easier. Maggie also finds herself attracted to Felicity's friend, Marcus (the typical bad boy with a heart of gold). Does she finally pick the authority figure or the rebel?
Overall, I thought the book was very well written for its genre. It was also very good (much better than average) for a first book. I do have a few quibbles, though. I felt that the secondary characters were a little too broadly drawn. The good guys are always good, and the bad guys are consistently villainous. That's pretty typical of the cozy mystery, though. There's also what seems to be a continuity problem in the scene in the cemetery. Maggie is telling someone something that she just told that same person in the previous chapter, and the other character seems surprised. I may be misinterpreting it, but I've read over this section more than once, and it alwoys seems a little strange to me.
The story is set in Stony Mill, Indiana, a small town in the northeastern part of the state. Alt describes the local area so well that it's almost possible, if you know the area, to pick out just where the fictional Stony Mill really is. Having grown up in the area, she knows how to describe both landscapes and residents perfectly. I enjoyed reading The Trouble With Magic very much, and would gladly recommend it to others. In fact, I did recommend it to our mystery group. Sure, it's light reading, but every now and then, that's just what you need. This book would be good for anyone who likes paranormal stories, cozy mysteries, or Hoosier authors and locations.